The Bullshit Meter: How Does Your OB Stack Up?
This has been the working title of a blog post I’ve been wanting to write for over a year now. I was in the process of collecting some key conversation points that might tip you off that something just isn’t quite right with what your doctor is telling you about your pregnancy and birth. However, since there are just so many ways to call “Bullshit!” when your OB does or says something to you during an appointment, writing the post became extremely daunting.
Disclaimer: When I say “OB” I’m really referring to whomever you choose as your provider throughout pregnancy and birth, who could also be a family physician or midwife. I simply defaulted to whom the majority of women in this country choose for maternity care. Also, be assured that there are many providers that do practice evidence-based care (care based on the safest outcomes). To find them; however, you first need to know what you are looking for.
Rather than continue with the writing I started, I’ll share excerpts from a publication that culls the knowledge of a team of birth professionals with decades of experience and add my own commentary.
Choices in Childbirth just published the 2009/2010 National Guide to a Healthy Birth, and I recommend that all pregnant women (whether first-time or veteran mothers) read this guide before their next prenatal appointment. It is packed with invaluable information, precisely the information that can be excluded from doctors’ offices and childbirth education classes. I cannot stress enough how important it is for women to access and utilize this resource.
A woman’s choice of care provider for her pregnancy and birth is the single most important decision she can make to determine the type of birth experience she will have.
Choosing one care provider over another can determine whether he will attend a VBAC (vaginal birth after cesarean) birth or not; allow eating and drinking in labor or not; approach pregnancy and birth as a physiological process or as a medically managed procedure, among a myriad of other decision points. I would also extend this level of consideration to the colleagues in your provider’s practice, as any of one of them may actually attend your birth.
Refer to the guide for questions to ask your provider. In all likelihood, these questions will spark questions of your own and encourage you to educate yourself on how decisions will impact your well-being and your baby’s well-being.
Receive accurate and up-to-date information about the benefits and risks of all procedures, drugs, and tests suggested for use during pregnancy, birth, and the postpartum period, with the rights to informed consent and informed refusal.
While certain procedures, drugs, and tests may be standard protocol for a particular provider or birth location, they may not be the safest options for you and your baby. Likewise, while certain procedures, drugs, and tests may be commonplace for your friends, family members, and the culture at large, they may not be the safest options for you and your baby.
Ask about, research, and understand the risks and benefits of procedures, drugs, and tests before agreeing to them. Know that you have a right to refuse them.
For example, EFM (electronic fetal monitors), the belt strapped across a woman’s belly to continuously track and record fetal heartrates, first made their way into maternity wards in the 1970’s. Although initially reserved for only “high-risk” women, EFM quickly became mandated by hospitals on nearly all laboring mothers. Despite over 30 years of routine use and upwards of 93% of women in labor wearing them, EFM has not improved outcomes – meaning rates of infant mortality, cerebral palsy, and infants requiring additional care immediately after birth in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit have not improved. Rates of Cesarean Section have not improved either, skyrocketing from 5% in 1970 to 31% in 2006.
Some questions that might arise as a result of discovering this information may be, “How does my provider monitor my baby’s well-being during labor? How does her method of monitoring affect my ability to move freely during labor? Is there an alternative to continuous EFM?”
To be sure you will get the kind of help you will need in labor, consider having a birth doula.
As much love as your life partner, friend, or family member may have for you, how experienced are they in witnessing and supporting women in birth? It can be difficult for a loved one to watch you move and sound in pain, hour after hour. How detached from the situation can this loved one become when you reach a challenging moment? Can the loved one push his or her anxiety aside and suggest just the right encouragement, just the right position change, just the right energy shift to buoy you along?
What about routine obstetric procedures and medical jargon? When you have a decision to make, can you rely on your loved one to accurately recall the evidence-based information that will help you make an informed decision? And then, can the loved one, once again, put his or her anxiety aside to communicate and ensure that the your needs and wishes are met?
Studies show that women who have doulas support them in birth experience lower rates of interventions (i.e. C-sections, vaccum deliveries, forceps deliveries, pain medications, augmented labors), shorter labors, and higher levels of satisfaction with their overall birth experience. Research also shows benefits that extend to the postpartum period, to infant-family bonding, and to women’s partners.
It is a good idea to interview at least two to three providers. It is never too late to change providers if you are not comfortable with the answers you receive.
Women choose their care providers for a variety of reasons. Maybe she’s done your pap smears for years. Maybe her office is convenienty located to your home or office. Or maybe she was recommended by a trusted friend. Whatever the reasons may be, they do not automatically qualify your provider to be the best fit for you in pregnancy in birth.
Some women may feel guilty for even thinking about switching providers, but this guilt is unwarranted. Just like any other service, if a client’s needs and wants don’t match up to what the provider can give, it’s time to move on and find someone with the proper skill set. Refer to the guide for a list of questions to ask.
Most believe PPD (Postpartum Depression) only happens to somebody else, but in reality it can strike any woman, either immediately after the birth of her baby or months after.
The transition into motherhood can be overwhelming enough. Add the variables of women being physically isolated from supportive family members, births becoming increasingly interventive, notions that asking for help is a sign of ineptitude, and proper breastfeeding support often being difficult to find, women can find themselves in utter dispair. Acknowledging possible PPD and finding appropriate support and treatment is crucial.
When labors are started artificially near or before your due date, babies are at risk of being born before their bodies are ready. This can lead to extra medical care, prolonged hospital stays, and, possibly, long-term effects on their brain function and learning abilities…Pharmaceutical induction before a woman’s body is ready for birth can lead to long, complicated labors. In fact, if it is your first baby, an induction of labor doubles your chances of having a cesarean section.
Without conducting fancy studies, one could easily ascertain the relative frequency of induced and augmented labors just by visiting online forums, reading Facebook status notices, watching so-called “reality” birth shows, and engaging in everyday conversations with others about birth. While it may be commonplace to read or hear that a woman’s labor was induced due to being “overdue”, having her water break, or carrying an estimated “big” baby, these are not automatic justifications for artificially starting labor.
How do you avoid an unnecessary induction (or any other unnecessary procedure, for that matter)? Educate yourself on physiological birth. Learn the risks and benefits of intervening in a healthy pregnancy and birth. Find a provider that practices maternity care in alignment with your needs and desires.
As the cesarean rate continues to climb year after year, it becomes increasingly important for women to have access to VBAC (vaginal birth after cesarean), and to more information about the benefits and risks of VBAC and repeat cesarean.
The World Health Organization states that when C-section rates rise above 10-15%, the dangers of surgery outweigh the lifesaving benefits it is supposed to provide. As of 2007, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention revealed that 31% of women underwent surgery to birth their babies, meaning over half of the C-sections in our country are unnecessary.
Why is this such a big deal? Having a C-section means higher rates of infertility, ectopic pregnancy, potentially severe placental problems in future pregnancies, among other risks for both mother and baby. In terms of future births, many providers will not “allow” their clients to have a vaginal birth after a cesarean birth, even though vaginal birth can be significantly safer than undergoing surgery again.
If you are a first-time mother, educate yourself and do all that you can to avoid a C-section. If you have given birth vaginally to previous children, continue to educate yourself by accessing resources like the 2009/2010 National Guide to a Healthy Birth. If you have given birth via cesarean, learn about the risks and benefits of repeat surgery and VBAC, and find a provider that will support you in your decision.
The guide also provides a list of C-section rates by state for the years 2000 and 2007. Notice the increase in surgical births. Also notice how greatly one state’s C-section rate varies from another. What’s happening in Florida that’s not happening in New Mexico and vice versa? While it is helpful to see the trends in your particular state, what’s going on in your city? At your hospital? With your provider? At local birth centers? With local, homebirth midwives?
You may not know that what you and others around you do in that very first hour of your baby’s life can have a significant — even lifelong — impact on the bond you have with your baby.
If you give birth at a location that attends a high volume of births (i.e. a hospital), many of the procedures before, during, and after birth are standardized. As a way of managing the sheer number of clients and their babies, a series of to-do lists are set in motion. Often clients do not question any of the items on these lists because clients assume that every item must safe and in the best interest of mothers and babies. Here again, this may not be true.
Read what Robert Sears, MD has to say about what may or may not be necessary immediately after birth and what will optimize that first hour after birth.
For many women, birthing at home or at a birth center, with a qualified and experienced provider, is a safe and legal option.
You may have heard the buzz about the documentary film, The Business of Being Born. You may have read about celebrities like Cindy Crawford and Gisele Bundchen giving birth at home. Or perhaps you may have heard about the 2005 study in the British Medical Journal that concludes homebirth is a safe and highly satisfying option for low-risk women. The awareness around maternity care is growing. Take a look around and discover the safest options for you and your children.
Like care providers, there are innumerable organizations and agencies that offer services of interest to birthing women.
It can be easy and tempting to simply go along with what “everyone else” seems to be doing, to be a “good” patient and not question any procedures, tests, or drugs that may cross your path during pregnancy and birth. It is understandable how many women can be driven by a culture of fear, especially after watching TV shows that only focus on what can go wrong and on misinformation.
But I ask you to rise above all of that, for your well-being and for your children’s well-being. Ask questions. Search for accurate information. Follow your intuition. Make informed decisions. Connect with communities that will support you in your journey to motherhood.











